Theater Review: ALL MY SONS (Lyric Stage, Boston)

all my sons lyric

WHAT’S BIGGER THAN THE FAMILY?

Lyric Stage’s intimate production of Arthur
Miller’s classic asks how far our responsibility
extends beyond those we call our own

Arthur Miller’s All My Sons is a haunting psychological American drama that takes place in 1947, capturing the postwar tension. The play is, first and foremost, a study of human responsibility and guilt as explored through the lens of family. These timeless themes bring a relevance that enables us to connect with the story despite the intervening 79 years. While enjoyable as a singular experience, it stands out as a thought-provoking piece on topics of identity, honor, and grief.

Director Scott Edmiston’s production takes advantage of the Lyric Stage’s intimate space and thrust stage, bringing us into the heart of the Keller family’s backyard—where the story unfolds. The Kellers are relatable, from their bickering to their hopes for a brighter future. However, beneath the veneer of middle-class America, Miller uses his characters—friends, family, neighbors—to explore where family, responsibility, and honor intersect.

World War II looms in the background of the events, kept alive through Larry, the son who never came home. Larry’s mother, Kate (Laura Marie Duncan), has never given up hope that he is alive, holding fast to the possibility of a miraculous return, even if it means living in limbo. Duncan’s performance is a blend of maternal desperation and fussiness as Kate leverages her grief to keep the family ready for Larry’s return.

While Kate uses the idea of Larry as a shield from facing the postwar reality, her husband, Joe (Bill Mootos), wants desperately to move on from the war and its direct aftermath. In his sixties, Joe sees the company he’s built as a shining legacy that he fought for in order to provide his surviving son, Chris (Mark Souza), with a stable future. Unwavering in his dedication to his wife and sons, Mootos commits to the character, from Joe’s easy bantering with Kate to his emotional revelation at the conclusion of the play.

Rounding out the Keller family, Chris brims with an idealism that sets him apart from his family and neighbors. From his bumbling attempts to woo his missing brother’s one-time girlfriend Ann “Annie” Deever (Josephine Moshiri Elwood) to his impassioned monologue chronicling his experience during the war and his struggle to reintegrate, Souza captures Chris’s spirit.

While the entire cast delivers strong performances in such a tight story, the three Kellers bring to life the very real consequences of responsibility and the ways that guilt can fester. Time is a recurring motif as the characters grapple with how to love and respect each other as a family while each of them struggles to overcome the trauma they’ve experienced.

As the Kellers struggle with moving on with their lives, the concept of family remains at the center of the story. Miller evolves the conflict from the question of whether Ann should still be “Larry’s girl” to the far more provocative question: Who does, and does not, fall under the protection of “family”? Intertwined with each of their interpretations of honor, the Kellers pursue the value of family through different avenues. This explores not only the definition of the family but also the weight that each of them places on the social construct as they envision their distinct futures.

All My Sons remains haunting because Miller’s central question has lost none of its force: Where does our responsibility end—with ourselves, with our families, or with people we may never know? Lyric Stage’s production leaves that question hanging long after the Keller family has answered it for themselves.

✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦

photos by Benjamin Rose

All My Sons
Lyric Stage Company of Boston
140 Clarendon Street in Boston
2 hours and 30 minutes with intermission
ends on October 25, 2026
for tickets, call 617.585.5678 or visit Lyric Stage

for more shows, visit Theatre in Boston

✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦

Leave a Comment





Search Articles

Please help keep
Stage and Cinema going!