ONCE UPON AN AMAZING TIME
Once is back at the Lamb’s Players Theatre for an extended run through March 30, glorious news for area playgoers. This is one of the must-see musicals of the early 21st century, a rare production that finds power in simplicity and emotion in restraint. As an additional bonus, local audiences are seeing a roadshow production filled with performers who had great success in its 2018 staging, ensuring a seamless blend of experience and fresh energy.
What makes Once so captivating is its ability to feel both deeply personal and universally resonant. It is fascinating, fresh, and touching without ever feeling contrived or overly theatrical. Unlike traditional Broadway musicals, it thrives on understatement, drawing the audience in with its hushed, aching beauty rather than show-stopping grandeur. Credit for this belongs to Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová’s exquisite music and lyrics, Enda Walsh’s thoughtful book, a spot-on cast of 13 extraordinarily talented actor-musicians, and the creative prowess of Lamb’s backstage team.
The story unfolds in a warmly immersive setting—a cozy Irish pub in present-day Belfast. The wooden bar, an integral part of the experience, isn’t just a set piece but a functional gathering spot where audience members can enjoy drinks before the show and during intermission. Before the story begins, the cast delights in a mini concert of songs from the Irish folk musical repertoire, setting the mood with joyous, foot-stomping authenticity. (Be sure to arrive early!)
At its core, Once tells the intimate love story of Guy (Michael Cusimano), a disillusioned Irish musician discouraged by his future in music and bummed out by his breakup with a former girlfriend, and Girl (Caitie Grady), an immigrant from the Czech Republic who sees his potential and urges him to follow his passion and persevere in his career. Their connection is immediate and profound, and Guy starts to gain acceptance for his music and his career builds. But their romance is complicated, tinged with both hope and melancholy. The musical’s bittersweet nature is one of its greatest strengths—it never forces a traditional happy ending but instead lingers in the space between love found and love lost, making it all the more poignant.
A standout element of Once is the way the cast serves as both the show’s orchestra and its heart. Each actor not only sings and dances, but plays at least one instrument, from guitars, violins, cello, ukulele, and mandolin to accordion, concertina, and percussion. This live, onstage orchestration creates a soundscape that is as authentic as it is beautiful, seamlessly shifting from soaring upbeat folk to hushed, tender ballads. The music is more than just accompaniment—it is a character in its own right, driving the narrative and revealing emotions left unspoken, and it is lovely to hear.
The entire ensemble deserves recognition, so here they are: In addition to Cusimano and Grady, the performers include Manny Fernandes, Kent Brisby, Charles Evans, Jr., Abigail Grace Allwein, Morgan Hollingsworth, Angela Chatelain Avila, Arusi Santi, Deborah Gilmour Smyth, James Michael McHale, Vanessa Dinning, and Dave Rumley. Young actors Gia Glenn and Iris Manter share a single cameo role with charm and assurance. Their collective chemistry, musicianship, and storytelling elevate the production into something truly special.
Behind the scenes, the creative team delivers brilliance across the board. Sean Fanning’s rustic, evocative set design, Jemima Dutra’s character-rich costumes, Nathan Peirson’s warm and atmospheric lighting, Patrick Duffy’s impeccable sound design, and Jessica Couto’s keen eye for detail in props all contribute to a world that feels fully lived in. Each element serves the story without distraction, reinforcing Once’s reputation as a show that relies on quiet power rather than spectacle.
This is a production that lingers long after the final note fades. Once is not just a musical—it is an experience, a testament to the beauty of music, the ache of longing, and the unexpected ways in which love can shape our lives. Whether you’ve seen it before or are experiencing it for the first time, don’t miss this extraordinary chance to be swept away.
photos by Ken Jacques
Once
Lamb’s Players Theatre
1142 Orange Ave in Coronado
Wed at 2 & 7; Thu & Fri at 7; Sat at 2 & 7; Sun at 2
ends on March 30, 2025
for tickets ($48-$118), call 619.437.6000 or visit Lamb’s Players
