Areas We Cover
Categories
Theater Review: ADIRONDACK CHAIR CIRCLE (Steppenwolf Theatre Company / Chicago)
by C.J. Fernandes | November 12, 2026
in Chicago, Theater
A MURDER OF CROWS,
A FLOCK OF FOOLS
A wickedly funny satire takes flight,
but its characters never quite get off the ground

Katrina Lenk, Sadieh Rifai and ensemble member Caroline Neff in Steppenwolf Theatre Company’s world premiere of Adirondack Chair Circle
Satire is a tricky genre to pull off in the best of circumstances, and even before the writing process has begun, the choice of target can make or break the entire enterprise. I’m not sure that it is possible to satirize Moms for Liberty, the right-wing, book-banning klatsch down in Florida, given that they are practically a parody unto themselves, as indeed, is the entire far right — sometimes I marvel that The Onion is still extant; what can they come up with that beats real headlines? — but playwright Stephanie Alison Walker has decided to give it the old college try, and I’m here for it.
Walker’s Adirondack Chair Circle is the second play in Steppenwolf’s current season, following their stunning revival of Topdog/Underdog. Directed by Pam MacKinnon, it opens with Todd Rosenthal’s lovely set, which depicts a verdant backyard in a posh, unnamed suburb of Chicago. Four red Adirondack chairs encircle (duh!) a firepit. There’s a stunning blue sky dotted with fluffy cumulus clouds. Under the gaze of a watchful Crow (David Darrow), Banna (Katrina Lenk) is setting out an elaborate charcuterie board in anticipation of her guests, the nervous and eager-to-please Winona (Wendy Mateo) and the spiteful and bitchy Libby (Sadieh Rifai, having the time of her life).
The three women have gathered to talk strategy. They’ve become aware of a scandalous book in the school library. The book boasts graphic sexual content, characters of non-normative sexuality, and I assume, plenty of sass. They are determined to have the book pulled from the library shelves. Their main opponents are Susan, the chairperson of the school board and Banna’s next-door neighbor, and another parent, Evelyn Grace (Caroline Neff), the mere mention of whom sends Libby into a nostril-flaring, snarling rage.
Adirondack Chair Circle gets off to a spectacular start with the Crow, who also serves as narrator. Banna is convinced that the Crow and his ilk are deliberately targeting her. She’s read that crows are fiercely loyal, and she’s seen Susan feeding him. She’s also entirely correct. Darrow is a hoot (wrong bird, I know) and deft at the physical comedy that requires him to hop onto the grass, dive-bomb Banna, and defecate on her accent tables — I … er, shit you not. This, combined with some hilarious dialogue — the name of the controversial book drew a snort from me — had me happily scribbling superlatives in my little pad. It also boasts a terrific comic score from Mikhail Fiksel that does a lot of heavy lifting in setting the tone of the play.
The first “uh oh” comes with the introduction of Evelyn Grace. This is not a knock on Caroline Neff, who is very fine in the part, but there is simply no nuance to the character; she’s so good she might as well have a halo. And her presence emphasizes the one-dimensionality of the others. Winona makes no sense whatsoever as a character, and Libby is so over-the-top nasty, she’s practically a cartoon villain. At least Rifai gets to have fun with the part, though, and she is absolutely delightful, chewing the scenery with abandon. Along with David Darrow — who also has a phenomenal scene as a different character in Act II — she steals the show.
Poor Katrina Lenk gets the worst of it all. Banna is an appalling piece of writing; less character than caricature, and embodying every left-wing stereotype of the hard-right female: she’s bored, she’s unhappy, her husband and trans child (that got an eye-roll) hate her, she has no purpose in life other than the book-banning. This is not satire. It’s reductive misogyny. That Lenk is brilliant only makes it worse.
Adirondack Chair Circle is an extremely funny play that’s preaching to the choir. I am about as left-wing as they come, but I don’t need to watch a play that merely mocks the hypocrisies of the self-righteous book-banners. I do that myself every time I read about them in the news. Except for Crow (which is Walker’s best idea), every beat of this script can be predicted by reading social media threads, right down to one character asking the other to define “woke.” In a tantalizing moment in the second act, Libby bemoans to Banna that “We have no power.” It’s a rare moment in the show where Walker leans into inductive reasoning, and for the first time Libby and Banna feel like real people — frustrated, embittered, and roiling within. I held my breath hoping she would push it further, that there would be an attempt to understand these angry women and what drives them. And then the moment passed, and they were back to being shrill harpies.
Oh well. I still laughed a lot. That’s something, I guess.
✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦
photos by Michael Brosilow
Adirondack Chair Circle
Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Ensemble Theater, 1646 N. Halsted Street, Chicago
Tue.–Fri. 7:30; Sat. 3 & 7:30; Sun. 3 (schedule exceptions apply)
2 hours and 25 minutes with intermission
ends on December 13, 2026
for tickets ($20–$167.50), call 312-335-1650 or visit Steppenwolf
for more shows, visit Theatre in Chicago
✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦






