Areas We Cover
Categories
Film Review: NUNS VS. THE VATICAN (Directed by Lorena Luciano)
by Paola Bellu | November 15, 2026
in Film
BEHIND THE HABIT,
A HABIT OF SILENCE
A documentary exposes the abuse of
religious women and the institutional
power that has kept their accusations buried
Making a documentary about allegations of sexual abuse against nuns within the Catholic Church is like covering a trial in which the accused appoints the judge and writes the verdict. One can imagine the difficulty, yet Italian director Lorena Luciano takes on this challenge in Nuns vs. the Vatican, a documentary that examines the abuse experienced by religious women at the hands of male clergy, and exposes the institutional silence that has allowed such allegations to remain hidden for decades. Formally speaking, this is hardly adventurous filmmaking, but the passion of those in front of and behind the camera more than compensates for the lack of cinematic fireworks.
At the center of the story is Gloria Branciani, a former nun who publicly accused Father Marko Ivan Rupnik, a former Jesuit priest, of sexual and spiritual abuse. A celebrated artist whose mosaics were intended to inspire contemplation and devotion, Rupnik was also a priest who enjoyed the favor of Pope John Paul II, later canonized as a saint. His reputation and connections within the highest echelons of the Church gave him extraordinary prestige.
Branciani, by contrast, was a very naive young woman when she entered the Loyola congregation in Ljubljana, Slovenia, that Rupnik had helped establish. He was the authority guiding her spiritual life; she describes how that trust was gradually transformed into control and exploitation, and how Rupnik sexually and spiritually abused her for years. Rupnik’s demands grew progressively more sordid and unreasonable, and she finally reached out, but her concerns were dismissed and belittled by the mother superior, Sister Ivanka Hosta, and other Church leaders. After enduring the cruel consequences of speaking out, she decided to share her story publicly and advocate for other women.
Written by Trevor Davidoski, Diana Golts, and Luciano, the documentary also features commentary and testimonies from tough women committed to raising awareness about clerical abuse, including journalists Lucetta Scaraffia and Federica Tourn, activist Barbara Dorris, and lawyer Laura Sgrò. Their contributions clarify the cultural, institutional, and legal dimensions of the issue, while the testimonies of other abused nuns provide the deeply personal narrative, conveying its human and emotional consequences. Among the most disturbing stories is that of a priest who impregnated a nun and then sought the help of a Vatican abortionist. During the illegal and traumatic procedure that involved, of all things, bleach, the doctor reportedly called the poor nun a whore who deserved to die.
Nuns vs. the Vatican is a story about the dangerous intersection of power, faith, and obedience. And it is precisely the rigid demands for obedience and modesty placed upon nuns and other religious women that often create an environment in which abuse is permitted and victims are silenced. By contrast, there are clips of Rupnik speaking in public in which he seems to enjoy weaving sexual innuendo into the language of religious devotion. References to giving one’s body unconditionally to Christ, or to the physicality of faith, carry an unmistakable double meaning. I cannot recall his exact words, but the suggestiveness was hard to miss. He must have felt untouchable, even as numerous nuns accused him, displaying the arrogance of a malignant narcissist.
It is worth remembering that the Catholic Church has more than 400,000 priests worldwide. In any institution of that size, there will inevitably be individuals who abuse their positions, betray the trust placed in them, or commit horrible acts. No institution can guarantee the moral character of every person within it, and sexual abuse has surfaced across Anglican, Protestant, Baptist, Pentecostal, and other Christian churches, as well as in other faith traditions worldwide. Unfortunately, the number of documented cases is never the number of actual cases. Fear of not being believed or of retaliation, “creative” record-keeping, access to archives, and the independence of investigations affect the figures we know about. That is precisely why this documentary matters.
✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦
Nuns vs. the Vatican
Film2 Productions
released October 23, 2026
U.S. | 2025 | 91 minutes | not rated | in English, Italian, Slovenian
for screenings and tickets, visit Fandango
✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦






