Off-Broadway Review: THE HEART (Roundabout / Laura Pels Theatre)

the heart the musical poster

A HEART THAT
BEATS FOR TWO

An astonishing musical transforms a heart
transplant into a celebration of humanity

Drew Gehling, Wren Rivera and the company of The Heart at Roundabout

Consider this story: A nineteen-year-old suffers a traumatic injury. He is pronounced brain-dead. A doctor approaches his parents to request an organ donation of his heart. The parents agree. The operation is performed, and the heart is transplanted to an ailing fifty-year-old woman.

Who could ever believe that a story like this could be told on the stage? And as a musical?! Can you imagine?! And yet it has been done, astonishingly, passionately, and unforgettably, by a team of dedicated, determined artistic collaborators.

Nick T. Daly, Max McKenna and the company

Christopher Ashley has transplanted his amazing production of The Heart from its original body (La Jolla Playhouse) to the Roundabout’s Laura Pels Theatre. It’s the first opening in his new tenure as Artistic Director of that vibrant theatre, and it promises to be one of the most powerful productions of the New York season.

It takes courage to produce a play on such a complex medical topic as this one—and (incredibly) as a musical, too. But Kait Kerrigan (book) and Anne and Ian Eisendrath (music and lyrics) have brought the story (based on Maylis de Kerangal’s novel) urgently to the stage under Mr. Ashley’s expert, inspired direction, giving us new insights into the fundamental meaning of life and the power of the theatre to illuminate it.

Joaquina Kalukango, Jason Tam

A superb ensemble of nine actors plays multiple roles in this momentous story, told over an intense twenty-four-hour period. Simon Lamar, the young San Diego surfer (the charming Nick T. Daley), has suffered a car accident while returning from his beloved pastime—surfing in the early-morning sea. In the emergency room, he’s immediately diagnosed as brain-dead. His estranged parents, Marianne (Joaquina Kalukango) and Sean (Jason Tam), meet at the hospital, where they are told the devastating news about their son and asked the urgent question: Will they allow his organs to be donated? An immediate response is needed. After agonizing, they agree. “You only get one wave,” Sean says, drawing on his son’s passion for surfing as life’s metaphor. “Drift away, go, be free,” his parents sing to him, as the body gets taken away.

We next meet Claire (Heidi Blickenstaff), celebrating her 50th birthday with family and friends. She has been suffering from heart failure for the past three years, awaiting a transplant, but has given up hope and accepts that she will soon die. The doctor interrupts the birthday festivities to announce that a heart is now available for her and requires immediate transplantation. “I’m not ready to die, but I’m not ready to live,” she responds, fearfully. Given the urgent timing, however, she agrees, and a spectacular operating room scene follows. In this climactic scene, we learn many technical aspects of the complex procedure of heart transplantation—but rather than overwhelm the audience, the heart surgeon Dr. Breva (Drew Gehling) clarifies its profound, universal purpose in a few words: “Not for myself, but for all.”

Drew Gehling, Max McKenna, Wren Rivera, Lincoln Clauss, Bre Jackson

What is so remarkable about Mr. Ashley’s direction is that, though Simon is brain-dead at the start of the story, he is kept moving constantly throughout the performance, observing the action. His agonizing parents surround his hospital bed while he sits to the side and watches them. He even participates in flashback scenes with his parents. So to us he’s very much alive. That is the crucial insight that Mr. Ashley and his collaborators are offering us: namely, that being alive has many meanings, the chief one being to give to others and show compassion towards those you know and those you don’t know. The play asks and answers the essential questions: What is our responsibility toward each other? What can we contribute to humanity?

The power of this production is intensified by the inspired design team that Mr. Ashley has assembled on Robert Brill’s set, with spectacular video projections by Lucy MacKinnon (featuring a heart, of course), lighting by Amanda Zieve, sound design by Gareth Owen, choreography by Mandy Moore) All the artistic elements—ensemble, design, musical score, choreography—combine, polished to perfection.

Drew Gehling, Heidi Blickenstaff, Nick T. Daly and the company

As such, The Heart is not a depressing play about loss and grief (though indeed we feel great empathy for the suffering of Simon’s parents). On the contrary: it’s a life-affirming play that celebrates “giving,” an act that will keep us all alive (including Simon). Mr. Ashley and Ms. Kerrigan make that clear in the play’s final, defining scene. It features a duet between Simon (the donor) and Claire (the recipient), who obviously never met. Simon, now dead, is very much “alive”—and so is Claire, thanks to Simon’s heart, which is now beating inside her. In a line of exquisite economy, Claire says to Simon: “I wish there was something I could… [pause]… Thank you.”

In that final metaphoric moment, we hear the beating of Simon’s heart inside Claire, projected on the upstage screen. It’s a universal heart that beats inside us all.

Could there be any other words than the following to illuminate the meaning of this powerful new play that teaches us compassion for humanity, so needed in these times? As the doctor says: “A life for a life; it’s just what you do.”

Nick T. Daly

✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦

photos by Joan Marcus

The Heart
Roundabout Theatre Company
Laura Pels Theatre, 111 W. 46th St. in New York
90 minutes, no intermission
ends on December 6, 2026
for tickets, visit Roundabout

✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦ ✦

Leave a Comment





Search Articles

Please help keep
Stage and Cinema going!